All questions Question A-1: What does 42 mean? #42 Question A-2: What's the License for arc42? #license #organization Question A-3: What's the pricing model of arc42? #license #pricing #organization Question A-4: How widely is arc42 used? #usage #organization Question A-5: What's the target audience of architecture documentation? #audience #reader #stakeholder Question A-6: What are possible alternatives to arc42? #alternative #sa4d Question A-7: I have additional questions... Question A-8: What is the master format for the template #asciidoc Question A-9: Where can I find documentation or tips? #help Question A-10: Can I change layout and/or header of arc42 documents? #help #license #layout Question A-11: What's the license of documents I created based upon the arc42 template? #license Question B-1: Which parts of arc42 are essential, which are optional? #method #essential #optional Question B-2: Does arc42 prescribe or enforce specific notations? #method #notation #UML #syntax Question B-3: Shall I use UML for arc42 documentation? #method #UML #notation #tools Question B-4: What is the minimal amount of an arc42 documentation? #method #minimal Question B-5: Where to document external interfaces? #method #interface #external #context Question B-6: How to document external interfaces? #method #interface #external #context Question B-7: Where to put links to external systems (neighbors) documentation? #method #interface #external #context Question B-8: What is a blackbox / the blackbox template? #method #template #blackbox #building-block Question B-9: What is a whitebox? #method #template #whitebox #building-block Question B-10: What is the building block hierarchy? #method #whitebox #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy Question B-11: How to document/specify a whitebox with the whitebox template? #method #whitebox #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy Question B-12 : Where shall I describe important (blackbox) components? #method #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy Question B-13: Can I use arc42 in agile projects, e.g. with Scrum? #method #agile #scrum #lean Question B-14: Can I update documentation incrementally? Or shall I document after the implementation is finished? #method Question B-15: What kind of information shall I provide for which stakeholder? #method #audience #stakeholder Question B-16: What does 'economical' documentation mean? #method #economical #pragmatic Question C-1-1: How extensive shall I describe the requirements of the system? #requirements #stakeholder Question C-1-2: What are quality goals (aka quality attributes)? #requirements #quality #scenario Question C-1-3: Why does arc42 propose a stakeholder table? #requirements #stakeholder Question C-1-4: What shall be included in a stakeholder table? #requirements #stakeholder Question C-1-5: What are the expected deliverables in the stakeholder table? #requirements #stakeholder Question C-1-6: In which cases shall we describe requirements more extensively? #requirements Question C-1-7: Where to document quality requirements? #requirements #quality #scenario #quality-tree Question C-2-1: What are constraints? #requirements #constraints Question C-2-2: What types of constraints exist? #requirements #constraints #organization #technical Question C-2-3: What kind of constraints shall I document? #requirements #constraints Question C-2-4: Can/shall we negotiate constraints? #requirements #constraints Question C-3-1: What is the context? #requirements #context #external-interface #_TBD Question C-3-2: What does _business_ and _technical_ context mean? #requirements #context Question C-3-3: Does it make any sense to show the major components of my application in the context view? #context #building-block Question C-3-4: In which cases shall I document the business context? #requirements #context Question C-3-5: How can I simplify documentation of the business context? #requirements #context #lean Question C-3-6: Shall I document risks or problems in the context? #requirements #context #risk Question C-4-1: What is the solution strategy? #solution-strategy Question C-4-2: How to document the 'solution strategy'? #solution-strategy Question C-4-3: Can you provide examples for the 'solution strategy'? #solution-strategy Question C-4-4: How is 'solution strategy' related to 'Quality goals' (section 1.2)? #solution-strategy #quality Question C-5-1: What is a 'building block'? #building-block Question C-5-2: Do third-party libraries, frameworks or tools count among building blocks? #building-block Question C-5-3: How does source code relate to building blocks? #building-block #source-code #hierarchy Question C-5-4: How detailed shall we document or specify the building block view? #building-block #economical #minimal Question C-5-5: Can I refine a group of building blocks together? #building-block #hierarchy Question C-5-6: How can I document or specify building blocks? #building-block #interface #template #blackbox Question C-5-7: How shall I document building blocks for non-object-oriented systems? #building-block Question C-5-8: How do I describe internal interfaces? #building-block #interface #internal Question C-5-9: How do I describe external interfaces? #building-block #interface #external Question C-6-1: What is the runtime view? What are runtime scenarios?? #scenario #runtime #view Question C-6-2: What do I document or specify in the runtime view? #runtime #scenario Question C-6-3: How can I describe scenarios or execution flows? #runtime #scenario #UML #sequence-diagram Question C-6-4: What are partial scenarios? #runtime #scenario #economical #lean #pragmatic Question C-6-5: Which scenarios shall I describe or document? #scenario #runtime Question C-7-1: What does the deployment view show? #deployment Question C-7-2: Why do I need a deployment view? #deployment Question C-7-3: Who shall describe/document the deployment view? #deployment #stakeholder Question C-7-4: Shall I use UML deployment diagrams for the deployment view? #deployment #UML #diagram Question C-7-5: Can there be different deployment scenarios or variants? #deployment #scenario Question C-7-6: What shall I do when my building blocks get dynamically assigned an execution environment (node) - so I cannot statically assign them to infrastructure nodes? #deployment Question C-8-1: What is a 'crosscutting concept'? #concept Question C-8-2: Our arc42 section 8 (on concepts) is a melting pot of information we couldn't put elsewhere? How can we keep an overview? #concept Question C-8-3: How shall I deal with the multitude of potentially crosscutting topics? #concept #_TBD Question C-8-4: How shall I describe my business-/domain model? #concept #domain #economical #_TBD Question C-8-5: Are there any general rules how to describe a 'concept'? #concept #pragmatic #economical Question C-8-6: What are candidates for 'concepts'? #concept #pragmatic #_TBD Question C-9-1: What kind of decisions shall I describe or document? #decision #quality #stakeholder Question C-9-2: How can I document an architectural decision? #decision Question C-9-3: What's an 'Architecture Decision Record' (ADR)? #decision Question C-9-4: How can we handle a 'large number' of architecture decisions? #decision Question C-10-1: What is 'Software Quality'? #quality Question C-10-2: What is a 'quality scenario'? #quality #scenario Question C-10-3: What is a 'quality tree'? #quality #_TBD Question C-10-4: Are there examples for quality scenarios? #quality #scenario Question C-10-5: Why is the 'Quality' section one of the last in the template, rather than being at the start? #quality #scenario Question C-11-1: What are 'risks' and 'technical debt'? #risk #technical-debt #problem Question C-12-1: Why is the glossary important? #glossary Question C-12-2: How can we describe important terms without much effort? #glossary #economical Question C-5-10: How can I avoid redundancy with interfaces in the building block view? #building-block #optional #interface Question C-5-11: How does the hierarchy of building blocks relate to the arc42 sections (5.1, 5.2 etc.)? #building-block #hierarchy Question C-5-12: What kind of building blocks don't I need to document or specify? #building-block #don't-do Question C-5-13: What kind of building blocks shall I document or specify? #building-block Question D-1: Why do I need a 'model'? I have source code. #model #abstraction Question D-2: What alternatives to UML exist for architecture models? #model #modeling #UML #alternative #C4 Question D-3: How do arc42 and UML relate to each other? #modeling #UML Question D-4: How can I use UML to communicate a hierarchy of building blocks? #modeling #UML #diagram #hierarchy #building-block Question D-5: How can I describe interfaces with UML? #modeling #UML #interface #diagram Question D-6: What can I use UML ports for? #modeling #UML #port #diagram Question D-7: How can I improve the 'understandability' of my diagrams/models? #modeling #diagram #stakeholder Question D-8: How can I reduce the number of elements in a component /building block diagram? #modeling #diagram #building-block Question D-9: How can I improve the consistency of models? #modeling #abstraction #consistency Question E-1: Does arc42 work with Scrum, Kanban or other lean/agile approaches? #agile #scrum #lean Question E-2: Shall our team make arc42 part of the definition of done (DoD)? #agile #scrum #lean Question E-3: How can arc42 help us in reducing documentation effort? #agile #lean #economical Question E-4: We use Scrum. How can we integrate arc42 into our sprints? #agile #scrum Question E-5: In agile projects, what kind of information shall we write down and what shall we communicate orally? #agile #lean #stakeholder Question E-6: In agile projects, can we skip (defer) documentation for a while and focus only on implementing? #agile #lean Question E-7: What are the most important tips for documentation in agile projects? #agile Question F-1: What tools are well-suited for arc42? #tools Question F-2: What are useful criteria for selecting a toolset for arc42? #tools #criteria Question F-3: Can I automatically include important code artifacts in arc42 documentation? #tools #import #source-code #asciidoc Question F-4: How do I use arc42 with modeling tools?? #tools #modeling Question F-5: How can I use arc42 together with (Sparx) Enterprise Architect®? #tools #modeling #EA #_TBD Question F-6: Are there (free or open-source) modeling tools available? #tools #modeling Question F-7: Can we use arc42 with (Atlassian) Confluence® wiki? #tools #wiki #confluence Question F-8: What tools can I use to setup arc42 in Confluence®? #tools #wiki #confluence Question F-9: How can I create diagrams in Confluence®? #tools #wiki #confluence #diagram Question F-10: What tools shall I use for sequence diagrams? #tools #sequence-diagram #plant-uml Question F-11: Can I use PlantUML for building block / component diagrams? #tools #diagram #plant-uml Question G-1: Shall I version control our architecture documentation? #versioning #organization Question G-2: We cannot use version control for documents. What to do? #versioning #organization Question G-3: How does versioning work with graphical models? #versioning #model #diagram Question G-4: How can I describe several 'variants' of a system? #versioning #stereotypes #_TBD Question H-1: What does 'traceability' mean (with arc42)? #traceability #requirements Question H-2: Shall we strive for traceability in our documentation? #traceability #requirements #_TBD Question H-3: How can I keep architecture documentation in sync with source code? #traceability #source-code Question J-1: How to document (very) large systems with arc42? #management #organization #large Question J-2: Does a _documentation governance_ make sense for architecture documentation?? #management #governance Question J-3: Is there a checklist for arc42 documentation? #management Question J-4: Is there a general checklist for architecture documentation? #management Question J-5: How can I create delta-documentation with arc42? #management #versioning #_TBD Question J-6: What level of access permissions shall stakeholders have on the architecture documentation? #management Question K-1: Are we allowed to customize arc42 for our (company/organization/system) purpose? #management #customization #license Question K-2: What kinds of customizations are common for arc42? #management #customization Question A-12: Is arc42 available in other languages? #language Question A-13: How can I translate arc42 to another language? #language, #translation Question B-17: What about arc42 and C4? #method #pragmatic Question F-12: How can I switch off the integrated help? #tools #asciidoc #plaintext
Question A-5: What's the target audience of architecture documentation? #audience #reader #stakeholder
Question B-7: Where to put links to external systems (neighbors) documentation? #method #interface #external #context
Question B-8: What is a blackbox / the blackbox template? #method #template #blackbox #building-block
Question B-10: What is the building block hierarchy? #method #whitebox #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy
Question B-11: How to document/specify a whitebox with the whitebox template? #method #whitebox #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy
Question B-12 : Where shall I describe important (blackbox) components? #method #blackbox #building-block #hierarchy
Question B-14: Can I update documentation incrementally? Or shall I document after the implementation is finished? #method
Question B-15: What kind of information shall I provide for which stakeholder? #method #audience #stakeholder
Question C-1-1: How extensive shall I describe the requirements of the system? #requirements #stakeholder
Question C-1-5: What are the expected deliverables in the stakeholder table? #requirements #stakeholder
Question C-1-7: Where to document quality requirements? #requirements #quality #scenario #quality-tree
Question C-3-3: Does it make any sense to show the major components of my application in the context view? #context #building-block
Question C-3-5: How can I simplify documentation of the business context? #requirements #context #lean
Question C-4-4: How is 'solution strategy' related to 'Quality goals' (section 1.2)? #solution-strategy #quality
Question C-5-2: Do third-party libraries, frameworks or tools count among building blocks? #building-block
Question C-5-3: How does source code relate to building blocks? #building-block #source-code #hierarchy
Question C-5-4: How detailed shall we document or specify the building block view? #building-block #economical #minimal
Question C-5-6: How can I document or specify building blocks? #building-block #interface #template #blackbox
Question C-5-7: How shall I document building blocks for non-object-oriented systems? #building-block
Question C-6-3: How can I describe scenarios or execution flows? #runtime #scenario #UML #sequence-diagram
Question C-7-4: Shall I use UML deployment diagrams for the deployment view? #deployment #UML #diagram
Question C-7-6: What shall I do when my building blocks get dynamically assigned an execution environment (node) - so I cannot statically assign them to infrastructure nodes? #deployment
Question C-8-2: Our arc42 section 8 (on concepts) is a melting pot of information we couldn't put elsewhere? How can we keep an overview? #concept
Question C-8-3: How shall I deal with the multitude of potentially crosscutting topics? #concept #_TBD
Question C-8-5: Are there any general rules how to describe a 'concept'? #concept #pragmatic #economical
Question C-10-5: Why is the 'Quality' section one of the last in the template, rather than being at the start? #quality #scenario
Question C-5-10: How can I avoid redundancy with interfaces in the building block view? #building-block #optional #interface
Question C-5-11: How does the hierarchy of building blocks relate to the arc42 sections (5.1, 5.2 etc.)? #building-block #hierarchy
Question C-5-12: What kind of building blocks don't I need to document or specify? #building-block #don't-do
Question D-2: What alternatives to UML exist for architecture models? #model #modeling #UML #alternative #C4
Question D-4: How can I use UML to communicate a hierarchy of building blocks? #modeling #UML #diagram #hierarchy #building-block
Question D-7: How can I improve the 'understandability' of my diagrams/models? #modeling #diagram #stakeholder
Question D-8: How can I reduce the number of elements in a component /building block diagram? #modeling #diagram #building-block
Question E-5: In agile projects, what kind of information shall we write down and what shall we communicate orally? #agile #lean #stakeholder
Question E-6: In agile projects, can we skip (defer) documentation for a while and focus only on implementing? #agile #lean
Question F-3: Can I automatically include important code artifacts in arc42 documentation? #tools #import #source-code #asciidoc
Question F-5: How can I use arc42 together with (Sparx) Enterprise Architect®? #tools #modeling #EA #_TBD
Question F-11: Can I use PlantUML for building block / component diagrams? #tools #diagram #plant-uml
Question H-2: Shall we strive for traceability in our documentation? #traceability #requirements #_TBD
Question H-3: How can I keep architecture documentation in sync with source code? #traceability #source-code
Question J-2: Does a _documentation governance_ make sense for architecture documentation?? #management #governance
Question J-6: What level of access permissions shall stakeholders have on the architecture documentation? #management
Question K-1: Are we allowed to customize arc42 for our (company/organization/system) purpose? #management #customization #license